FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

August 29, 2024

Orleans Parish Jury Finds Preston Higgs Guilty in the 2021 Murder of Liz Quackenbush

New Orleans, LA – After a tense and highly emotional three-day trial, a jury found Preston Higgs guilty of the 2021 murder of his girlfriend, beloved Liz Quackenbush. This verdict brings a measure of justice for Liz’s family after more than three years of heartache and uncertainty.

Higgs was apprehended in Indiana following a relentless 18-week nationwide manhunt, led by the United States Marshals Service, which brought him back to face trial in Louisiana. The Orleans Parish District Attorney’s Office, with District Attorney Jason Williams and Assistant District Attorney Penny Kissinger, was present when the jury delivered the long-awaited verdict.

The prosecution’s case was built on compelling evidence, including a critical 911 call made by Higgs’ uncle in Minnesota. The uncle’s urgent plea for first responders to check on Liz at her Desire Street home revealed chilling details relayed by Higgs’ family members. The call described how “Preston hit his girlfriend in the head with a weapon, that she was dead, and that the incident occurred on the previous day.” This evidence led authorities to the scene where the murder weapon was found, solidifying the case against Higgs.

Assistant District Attorney Penny Kissinger’s closing statement underscored the brutality of the crime: “If the wounds to the front of her head were incapacitating, the wounds from the back must have come first. It’s easy to tell any story when the other witness is dead. He was pulled off a Greyhound bus in Chicago with a fake ID and a burner phone in his pocket. All he had to do was leave, but instead, he obliterated her face and left the axe on her. Preston Higgs is a liar. There is no reasonable doubt that he murdered Elizabeth Quackenbush.”

Liz Quackenbush, 39, was more than a dedicated chemistry teacher at New Harmony High School—she was a source of inspiration and warmth for everyone she met. Known for her innovative teaching, she created the “Outdoor Adventures” program, which brought science and math to life through activities like gardening and kayaking. Her enthusiasm and commitment to her students left a lasting impact on all who knew her.

District Attorney Jason Williams reflected on the loss, saying, “Liz was a remarkable woman who touched the lives of her students, colleagues, and everyone fortunate enough to know her. Her tragic death leaves a void that can never be filled, but today’s verdict is an essential step toward justice for Liz and her family.”

District Attorney Jason Williams reflected on the loss, saying, “Liz was a remarkable woman who touched the lives of her students, colleagues, and everyone fortunate enough to know her. Her tragic death leaves a void that can never be filled, but today’s verdict is an essential step toward justice for Liz and her family.”

Liz’s mother, Dianne Holland, shared the ongoing pain of losing her daughter in such a brutal manner. She addressed the media, speaking of the horror of learning that her daughter had been murdered. She also expressed the continued pain each time she and her family had to return to court – to forced to relive the details of Liz’s death. The was clearly unbearable, but she honored her daughter by seeing it through to the end.

This case could not have been fought without the hard work of Assistant District Attorney Penny Kissinger, trial assistant Diene Jiles, and Victim Advocate Liz Herron. DA Williams was personally compelled to see to it that he did everything within his power to see that justice was served for this family. The District Attorney gave a special recognition to the U.S. Marshals Service for their dedication in tracking down Higgs and ensuring he was brought to justice.

As the community continues to mourn the loss of a cherished teacher and friend, the Orleans Parish District Attorney’s Office reaffirms its commitment to seeking justice for all victims of violent crime. The trial highlighted the tireless efforts of law enforcement and the enduring resilience of Liz Quackenbush’s family and friends, serving as a powerful reminder of the lasting impact of such heinous acts.

Criminal District Court Section E Judge Rhonda Goode-Douglas, who presided over this case, has scheduled sentencing for October 3, 2024.